Honestly, all of these points are bad except for #7. Silent Hill isn't action/horror, so it doesn't need "enemy variety" (especially the second game). People who complain about that either want Silent Hill 2 to be Silent Hill 3 (even though it's not supposed to be), or they want a Resident Evil game.

The biggest thing to improve from the last one is to tone down the combat, monster density, unsubtle jum♒pscares, excessive padding, and over-the-top🎃 nonsense.