Summary
- Ravensburger has announced the first errata for Lorcana, which massively nerfs Bucky, Squirrel Squeak Tutor.
- Although the strange errata did raise some concerns at first, Ravensbuger's explanation has made it make more sense.
- The main reason is so that future players can have a "fully playable experience", although it's not above banning a card in the future.
I don't think anyone was expecting this: after just six weeks of spreading terror across the Inklands, Ravensburger has decided to nerf Bucky, Squirrel Squeak Tutor Despite launching in Rise of 🤡the Floodborn, Bucky is the centerpiece of a high🎃ly-oppressive discard deck that has gained popularity since the launch of Ursula’s Return in May thanks to its synergy with new, low-cost Floodborn characters.
To fix the problem, Ravensburger has decided to increase Bucky’s cost, remove his Ward keyword, and change his ability to only trigger when you play a Floodborn character using Shift. This is the most extreme errata we’ve seen in so far, and the first time a card’s text has been altered for the sake of power balance. Not only is this a first for Lorcana, but this also iꦚsn’t something trading card games typically do at a🎃ll.
Every Card Revealed For Disney Lorcana's Shimmering Skies
It's♏ time for a celebration with Disney Lorcana's fifth set, Shimmering Skies.
With so many cards added to the pool so frequently, overpowered cards and unintended interactions are inevitable in any card game. Whenever this happens in games like and , the developers will often decide to ban the card outright, making it illegal for competitive play. Magic’s ban list is ever-growing across all of its various formats, and while it's less common for The Pokemon Company to ban cards (ther𒀰e are only 24 on the Expanded list and none in Standard currently), it has banned cards from Standard a𒐪s recently as 2020.
Bucky's Errata Seemed To Set A Wild Precedent For Lorcana
Both companies have errata’d cards that were either too strong or not strong enough before, but it’s rare. A lot of the iconic Pokemon items that have been part of the game since the very beginning have needed updates to bring them up to a competitive standard over the years. Magic famously changed the C🌠ompanion mechanic sಞhortly after its debut in 2020, and required you to pay a three-mana cost to move them from th꧃e sideboard to your hand before playing it, instea🅰d of being able to cast it from outside the game outright.
What Ravensburger is doing with Bucky is something you never really see outside of digital card games. Hearthstone is notorious for routinely changing card costs, keywords, and abilities, sometimes multiple times on the same card, as a way to balance and, sometimes, just to shake up the meta when it gets stale. But for obvious reasons, you can’t just c✃hange a physical card the way you can a digital one, so while most Lorcana players are happy to see the Bucky go away, the method chosen here has proven to be controversial.
It’s a strange approach. Taking away Bucky’s Ward or changing his ability to only trigger off of Shift likely would have been enough to bring him in line, but by changing both, and increasing his cost by one, Ravensburger has seemingly made the cardꦡ unplayable, effectively banning it without banning it. It makes sense to be heavy-handed here. You can’t make incremental changes in Lorcana the way you can in Hearthstone, and one errata is an unfortunate situation, multiple errata on the same card would be a disaster.
Still, why make the card unplayable, and potentially risk confusing new players, when a ban would be so much simpler? More importantly,ꦐ is this indicative of what Ravensburger’s approach to balance problems will be in the fut🐽ure?
Here's Why Bucky Was Given Such A Big Nerf
I started writing this to weigh the pros and cons of errata, but fu▨rther clarification from . Brady says the Bucky nerf is a special c𒁏ase because Ravensburger is planning support for additional languages and wants future players to have a “fully playable experience”, rather than having one less card in Emerald. Brady also explains that Ravensburger is willing to ban cards in the future if necessary, and that that strategy is preferable to this kind of drastic errata.
Reading between the lines a bit, it seems like the issue is that Ravensburger plans on printing Rise of the Floodborn in other languages sooner rather than later, and given the choice between reworking the card and shipping the set with 203/204 card🐷s, it chose the former. This is an important context that should help alleviate concerns about this strange errata.
Magic: The Gathering had a similar situation with the recent release of Modern Horizons 3 including the recently banned-in-Mo🔴dern card Fury. However, Magic’s multiple formats meant it was still playable elsewhere, so it wasn’t as de𓂃ad a card as Bucky would be.
Does this nerf go too far? It’s too soon🦩 to tell. While a three-cost Ward-less Bucky that triggers when you Shift a character into play is pretty much unplayable in the current format thanks to a plethora of new cards that target l🅘ow-strength characters (Sisu, Daring Visitor; Brawl, Madame Medusa) we don’t know what Shimmering Skies will bring that could make this new Bucky relevant.
Making this decision so quickly could indicate tꦇhat the discard archetype is getting even more powerful tools in the next set that would have made Bucky even more oppressive. The squirrel might be dead for now, but ൩there’s no way to know whether this nerf was too much until we see the next set, i.e., when the nerf actually goes into effect.
I applaud Ravensburger for taking immediate action to address an issue. While it performed well this set, taking the top win at DLC Chicago last month and over-performing at cash events all over, the real issue isn’t how good it is, but how miserable it is to play against. That’s what Ravensburger identified as the reaso♒n for the nerf, and I’m happy to see that the s🎶tudio is weighing both win rates and player sentiment when it makes these big decisions. Whether you agree with the errata or would have preferred a full-blown ban, it’s just good that the reign of the squirrel is ending.
Every Card In Magic: The Gathering's Bloomburrow
Head to Valley and meet woodland creatur𓂃es in Magic: The Gathering's cozy set, Bloomburrow.
